Revise a research question when the evidence cannot answer it
A before-and-after sequence is not a controlled comparison. Narrowing the question to observed change produces a defensible answer.
Start here
This example uses the sample details below. Replace them with your own facts before applying the instructions.
- Request asks whether a headline caused more sales; only totals supplied.
Start with the facts
Request asks whether a headline caused more sales; only totals supplied. Keep the source, date and scope of each observation. A gap in the evidence is a question to investigate, not a fact to fill in.
Spot the problem
The wording or action to avoid is: “The new headline caused the sales increase.” A before-and-after sequence is not a controlled comparison. Narrowing the question to observed change produces a defensible answer.
Make the correction
The totals changed after the edit, but other changes and comparable observations are needed to assess causation.
Check before using the result
Record price, advertising, traffic and season changes alongside the edit before interpreting the totals.
Worked example and reusable input
Use the stated inputs to reproduce checked local outputs. Replace sample facts when applying a brief to your own work.
TASK Revise a research question when the evidence cannot answer it SAMPLE INPUT — replace with your actual facts Request asks whether a headline caused more sales; only totals supplied. AVOID The new headline caused the sales increase. CORRECTED APPROACH The totals changed after the edit, but other changes and comparable observations are needed to assess causation. ACCEPTANCE CHECK Record price, advertising, traffic and season changes alongside the edit before interpreting the totals.
Key takeaways
- A before-and-after sequence is not a controlled comparison. Narrowing the question to observed change produces a defensible answer.
- Record price, advertising, traffic and season changes alongside the edit before interpreting the totals.